Manipur vs. Bihar: The Tale of the Mithila Makhana GI Tag

India's diverse culinary landscape is a tapestry woven with unique ingredients and traditional practices, many of which are protected by Geographical Indication (GI) tags. These tags certify a product's origin and distinct qualities, safeguarding its heritage. Recently, a fascinating chapter unfolded in this narrative involving the humble yet mighty makhana (fox nut), as Manipur and Bihar both vied for a GI tag. The outcome? A significant win for the Mithila Makhana GI Tag, spotlighting Bihar's deep-rooted connection to this aquatic crop.

Understanding Geographical Indications (GI Tags)

A Geographical Indication (GI) is a sign used on products that have a specific geographical origin and possess qualities or a reputation due to that origin. Think of Darjeeling Tea, Basmati Rice, or Mysore Silk – these are all Indian products protected by GI tags. The purpose of a GI is twofold: to protect the intellectual property rights of a community whose livelihoods are tied to a traditional product, and to assure consumers of the product's authenticity and quality.

  • Protection: Prevents unauthorized use of a GI by third parties whose products do not conform to the applicable standards.
  • Economic Benefit: Boosts demand and value, leading to economic prosperity for local communities.
  • Cultural Preservation: Helps in preserving traditional knowledge, practices, and biodiversity associated with the product.

Globally, GI tags are recognized under the World Trade Organization’s (WTO) Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS).

Bihar's Claim: The Legacy of Mithila Makhana

For centuries, the Mithila region of Bihar has been synonymous with makhana cultivation. Bihar is the largest producer of makhana in India, accounting for over 80% of the total production. The 'Mithila Makhana' is particularly renowned for its traditional methods of cultivation, harvesting, and processing, primarily carried out in ponds and water bodies across districts like Darbhanga, Madhubani, Purnia, and Katihar. The process is labor-intensive, involving careful collection of seeds from pond beds, sun-drying, and then roasting and popping by skilled artisans.

The unique agro-climatic conditions of the Mithila region, combined with the generations-old expertise of its farmers and processors, contribute to the distinct quality, taste, and texture of Mithila Makhana. This deep historical and cultural linkage formed the cornerstone of Bihar's application for the Mithila Makhana GI Tag, which was eventually granted in August 2022 by the Geographical Indications Registry.

Manipur's Perspective: The Unique Loktak Makhana

While Bihar celebrated its GI tag, Manipur had also presented a compelling case for its own unique variety of fox nut, known locally as 'Loktak Makhana' or 'Heikak'. What makes Manipur's claim particularly intriguing is its distinct method of cultivation. Unlike Bihar's pond-based farming, Loktak Makhana is primarily harvested from Loktak Lake, the largest freshwater lake in Northeast India, famous for its 'phumdis' – floating islands of vegetation, soil, and organic matter.

The makhana plants here grow naturally on these phumdis, making the cultivation process an integral part of the lake's unique ecosystem. This method, involving unique aquatic farming techniques and minimal human intervention in the initial growth stages, yields a product with slightly different characteristics and a strong local identity. Manipur's argument hinged on this distinct ecological niche and traditional harvesting practices associated with the Lake, highlighting a biodiversity that deserved its own recognition. Although a separate GI tag for Loktak Makhana was not granted in the same decision, its unique nature remains acknowledged within the broader discussion of India's indigenous food systems.

The GI Application Process and Resolution

The process for obtaining a GI tag in India is rigorous, involving thorough documentation, examination, and often, extensive research into historical evidence, traditional practices, and scientific data proving the product's uniqueness. Both Bihar and Manipur submitted their respective claims, presenting their case for why their particular makhana deserved the coveted tag.

The GI Registry, after evaluating all submissions, granted the Geographical Indication (GI) tag to 'Mithila Makhana' in August 2022. This decision recognized the long-standing tradition and the unique qualities imparted by the Mithila region's environment and cultivation practices. While Manipur's 'Loktak Makhana' is undeniably unique, the specific criteria for the initial GI application likely favored Bihar's extensive documentation and established commercial production history under the 'Mithila Makhana' name. This outcome underscores the competitive and often complex nature of GI applications, where distinctiveness and demonstrable regional linkage are paramount.

Beyond the Plate: Cultural Significance and Economic Impact

The granting of the Mithila Makhana GI Tag is far more than just a label; it's a testament to the rich agricultural heritage of Bihar and a significant step towards empowering its makhana farming communities. This recognition is expected to:

  • Boost Farmer Income: Premium pricing and increased market access for authentic Mithila Makhana.
  • Prevent Misappropriation: Protects the product from being misused by producers from other regions.
  • Promote Tourism: Highlights the Mithila region and its unique agricultural practices, potentially attracting agri-tourism.
  • Preserve Traditional Knowledge: Encourages the younger generation to continue traditional cultivation and processing methods.

Similarly, recognizing and understanding the distinctiveness of Loktak Makhana, even without a separate GI tag at this point, contributes to the broader appreciation of India's diverse agro-ecological systems and the need to support all traditional food producers.

Conclusion: Celebrating India's Culinary Diversity

The Manipur vs. Bihar plate, in the context of makhana, illustrates the dynamic world of Geographical Indications and the immense value placed on regional food identities. While the Mithila Makhana GI Tag now proudly represents Bihar's legacy, the spotlight also falls on Manipur's unique Loktak Makhana, reminding us of the incredible biodiversity and traditional knowledge systems that thrive across India. We encourage you to seek out and savor GI-tagged products, not just for their authentic flavors, but also to support the communities and traditions that bring them to our tables. What's your favorite GI-tagged Indian food? Share your thoughts in the comments below!

References: